The smart way to improve grades

Comprehensive & curriculum aligned

Affordable pricing from £10/month

Evidence for evolution

In this worksheet, students will discuss the evidence for evolution and how theories have developed over time when new evidence has been presented.

'Evidence for evolution' worksheet

Key stage:  KS 4

Curriculum topic:  Biology: Evolution, Inheritance and Variation

Curriculum subtopic:  Natural Selection and Evolution

Difficulty level:  

down

Worksheet Overview

QUESTION 1 of 10

The world we live in was a very different place millions of years ago. Most of the organisms we know now did not exist. Instead, dinosaurs lived all over the Earth. We know this from fossil records. So what happened, how did humans come to rule the earth if we didn’t even exist 16 million years ago? Well, evolution is the answer.

 

Charles Darwin came up with the idea of evolution through natural selection in the 1800s when he was on a cruise from Africa all the way around the bottom of South America and up the Galapagos islands. When he published his findings, there was an outcry, and rightly so! People thought that God had made everything and so they didn’t want to believe in Darwin. There where a lot of good questions that scientists asked, like ‘How can something as complicated as the eye evolve from natural selection only?’ and ‘Where is the evidence?’

 

This was a real problem for Darwin – he really believed in his hypothesis and he had some evidence, like finches that were adapted to live on one specific island only. But he was lacking a big piece of the puzzle, fossils that we could trace back.

 

Fossils are the imprints of dead plants and animals that turned into stone over millions of years. Some species, like the horse, have changed significantly over time and we know this because we have a complete fossil record of the horse. This is called evolution. We do not have fossil records for all organisms. For example, we don’t have a complete fossil record for Humans.

 

After Darwin died, people started to show that his hypothesis was correct by giving evidence from the fossil record of different animals. The more and more evidence started to build up, the more and more people believed in his hypothesis until one day, there was so much evidence that this could be the only explanation and Darwin’s hypothesis became a theory.

 

Today, we have DNA evidence as well, showing us that animals are related to other animals that look similar. This has been a huge piece of evidence that makes the theory of evolution irrefutable, meaning that we have so much evidence to support the theory that it has to be correct.

 

Finally, the real breakthrough came – we observed evolution in action. Normally it takes millions of years for organisms to evolve, but it only takes bacteria a short time. We now have a branch of bacteria called MRSA that didn’t exist 60 years ago. It has evolved to deal with the use of antibiotics (chemicals that kill bacteria) by humans and it is now immune to most of our antibiotics.

 

 

 

Let's explore evolution into more depth by going through some questions.

 

A few years ago, scientists discovered the 12 000 year old remains of an adult human, just one metre tall. These tiny people that lived in Indonesia were given a nickname: 'Hobbits'. 

'Hobbits' had skulls the size of a grapefruit, but were still intelligent enough, as they were able to make tools. Like primates, they had long arms. Where do you think they lived and why?

In the sea, because long arms help in swimming.

In trees, because long arms help in climbing and swinging on branches.

In caves, because long arms help in excavating.

Bones and shells decay much more slowly than other parts of the body. These parts are usually the ones that fossilise. When dead animals are covered with sediment (soil and rocks that sink to the bottom of the sea), they are buried and bones and shells are replaced by minerals, which then turn into stone and form a fossil. Can you see the layers on the rock in the picture below? 

 

A rock that has been eroded away so that you can see the layers in the sediment.

 

Fossil A was found in the top layer of the rock, whereas fossil B was found in the bottom layer. Which fossil is the oldest one?

A

B

Observe this picture of a fossil:

 

 

Select the type of organism you think was fossilised. 

Plant

Fungus

Animal

Tick two reasons we now accept evolution as being a fact.

Organisms evolve to adapt and survive in their environment.

DNA evidence can help us to form family trees.

We have observed bacteria evolving to defend against antibiotics.

All organisms have a complete fossil record.

Look at the picture below, showing how horses evolved over millions of years. Observe that horses actually had toes to start with, which were gradually replaced by a hoof.

 

 

Why do you think horses evolved to have hooves instead of toes?

Hint: Over 60 million years ago horses lived in the rain forest.

They were adapted to hunting wild animals.

They were less noisy.

They were adapted to walking on the forest floor, which was soft.

 

Seals are good swimmers, because they are adapted to swimming in the sea. If a whale chases a group of seals, what will most probably happen? Two options are correct.

The faster seals will escape

The slower seals may be eaten

Swimming slowly helps seals to survive

The fast seals will be eaten

Select 2 reasons that people didn't believe Darwin when he presented his theory of evolution in 1850.

There was not a complete fossil record.

DNA evidence showed that humans and apes are not related.

People believed that God made all of the animals.

If a species does not evolve to adapt to changing conditions it will become extinct.

According to Jean Baptiste de Lamarck, organisms acquire characteristics throughout their lifetime and then pass them on to their offspring. For example, if a giraffe has to reach leaves on high branches, it stretches its neck and passes on this characteristics to its young.

This theory is not correct, explain why.

A giraffe's neck can stretch during its lifetime.

A long neck would be coded for by a gene and it would pass to the young through DNA.

All giraffes have long necks.

Look at the picture of the peppered moth against lichen that grows on a tree bark. There are also dark moths, which would not be as well camouflaged as the one in the picture. Dark moths camouflage better on tree barks. The lichen that grows on trees in the countryside does not survive in polluted cities.

 

 

Where is it most likely to find dark moths?

Polluted areas

Unpolluted areas

Complete the sentence below by typing the missing word in the box.

Antibiotic resistant bacteria such as MRSA is an example of modern day ________________.

  • Question 1

A few years ago, scientists discovered the 12 000 year old remains of an adult human, just one metre tall. These tiny people that lived in Indonesia were given a nickname: 'Hobbits'. 

'Hobbits' had skulls the size of a grapefruit, but were still intelligent enough, as they were able to make tools. Like primates, they had long arms. Where do you think they lived and why?

CORRECT ANSWER
In trees, because long arms help in climbing and swinging on branches.
EDDIE SAYS
Most probably, long arms mean that they lived in trees. Scientists were led to that conclusion because they know what primates look like today and where they live. These animals are adapted to their environment and are an example of evidence of an organism related to humans. Beware, not even scientists can be 100% sure about this, so don't worry if you got it wrong. The main point is to start thinking scientifically!
  • Question 2

Bones and shells decay much more slowly than other parts of the body. These parts are usually the ones that fossilise. When dead animals are covered with sediment (soil and rocks that sink to the bottom of the sea), they are buried and bones and shells are replaced by minerals, which then turn into stone and form a fossil. Can you see the layers on the rock in the picture below? 

 

A rock that has been eroded away so that you can see the layers in the sediment.

 

Fossil A was found in the top layer of the rock, whereas fossil B was found in the bottom layer. Which fossil is the oldest one?

CORRECT ANSWER
B
EDDIE SAYS
The deepest rocks in the Earth contain older fossils, because they were buried first. Then, more fossils were buried in the layers above them, so B is the oldest one, as it was found in the bottom layer.
  • Question 3

Observe this picture of a fossil:

 

 

Select the type of organism you think was fossilised. 

CORRECT ANSWER
Plant
EDDIE SAYS
This is a fossilized plant and you can tell by the shape; it looks like a leaf. Yes, plants can also turn into stone!
  • Question 4

Tick two reasons we now accept evolution as being a fact.

CORRECT ANSWER
DNA evidence can help us to form family trees.
We have observed bacteria evolving to defend against antibiotics.
EDDIE SAYS
Not all organisms have a complete fossil record, mainly because there are so many fossils that have not been discovered yet. However, perhaps some organisms did actually disappear, i.e. they went extinct and then others took their place. This does not contradict the theory of evolution.
  • Question 5

Look at the picture below, showing how horses evolved over millions of years. Observe that horses actually had toes to start with, which were gradually replaced by a hoof.

 

 

Why do you think horses evolved to have hooves instead of toes?

Hint: Over 60 million years ago horses lived in the rain forest.

CORRECT ANSWER
They were adapted to walking on the forest floor, which was soft.
EDDIE SAYS
The rain forest floor was soft and muddy, so toes meant there was a bigger surface area to spread the weight, in order for the horse not to sink. With time, horses developed hooves which are good for running over open country, because their environment had changed.
  • Question 6

 

Seals are good swimmers, because they are adapted to swimming in the sea. If a whale chases a group of seals, what will most probably happen? Two options are correct.

CORRECT ANSWER
The faster seals will escape
The slower seals may be eaten
EDDIE SAYS
Most likely, the seals that are better adapted to swimming fast will escape the whale and survive, whereas the slower ones may be eaten. Does it make sense? Well done! You need to use common sense to understand evolution.
  • Question 7

Select 2 reasons that people didn't believe Darwin when he presented his theory of evolution in 1850.

CORRECT ANSWER
There was not a complete fossil record.
People believed that God made all of the animals.
EDDIE SAYS
You need evidence to be able to back up your theory - if you don't have evidence then what you are presenting is a hypothesis. While Darwin had some evidence, he didn't have the overwhelming evidence that we have now and so at the time, people were right to question Darwin's theory. We now have overwhelming evidence so we can believe in evolution.
  • Question 8

According to Jean Baptiste de Lamarck, organisms acquire characteristics throughout their lifetime and then pass them on to their offspring. For example, if a giraffe has to reach leaves on high branches, it stretches its neck and passes on this characteristics to its young.

This theory is not correct, explain why.

CORRECT ANSWER
A long neck would be coded for by a gene and it would pass to the young through DNA.
EDDIE SAYS
According to the correct theory of evolution by Darwin, only the giraffes with long necks would be able to reach the only food available. Those giraffes would live to reproduce, so their young would also have long necks. Option 2 is the correct one.
  • Question 9

Look at the picture of the peppered moth against lichen that grows on a tree bark. There are also dark moths, which would not be as well camouflaged as the one in the picture. Dark moths camouflage better on tree barks. The lichen that grows on trees in the countryside does not survive in polluted cities.

 

 

Where is it most likely to find dark moths?

CORRECT ANSWER
Polluted areas
EDDIE SAYS
Peppered moths camouflage better on tree barks with lichen growing on them, so they live in the countryside where lichen grows. Dark moths survive better against dark background in polluted cities.
  • Question 10

Complete the sentence below by typing the missing word in the box.

Antibiotic resistant bacteria such as MRSA is an example of modern day ________________.

CORRECT ANSWER
evolution
EDDIE SAYS
Microbes that are not killed by antibiotics survive to pass on their DNA to the next generation. This results in their population gradually becoming resistant to antibiotics. This is recent evolution in action.
---- OR ----

Sign up for a £1 trial so you can track and measure your child's progress on this activity.

What is EdPlace?

We're your National Curriculum aligned online education content provider helping each child succeed in English, maths and science from year 1 to GCSE. With an EdPlace account you’ll be able to track and measure progress, helping each child achieve their best. We build confidence and attainment by personalising each child’s learning at a level that suits them.

Start your £1 trial

Start your trial for £1